Book Review: The Starless Sea

Morgenstern’s The Starless Sea melodically tells the tale of booklover and son of a fortune-teller Zachary Ezra Rawlins as he ventures into his story, one beneath the earth in gilded caverns of books and glowing ballrooms. After stumbling upon an old, author-less book in his university’s library, he realizes he is one of the characters within it. Trying to figure out how this could be, he traces the origins of the book and finds himself at a high class, literary-themed party. There, he meets Dorian and Mirabel, learns the truth of the Starless Sea, and goes on an adventure to save it and those he loves.

Click on the image to go to the Goodreads review

Before I begin, I must explain that although this book deserves every one of its five stars, it is not a book for everyone. This fantastical ode to storytelling blurs the lines of myth and reality, often leaving the reader lost or without explanation. Or even worse– without the satisfaction of expected closure. Storytelling is diverse, each culture having its own set of rules for what constitutes a tale and what the morals must be, so thus these “faults” feel less so. I think of the movie Pan’s Labyrinth, and how the viewer never gets a clear answer on if the magical world is real or not. The point is not to investigate every last frame trying to find the answer, but rather that it is Schrödinger’s cat in nature, with both possibilities true and untrue at once. In the same way, this book lets you experience a story within a story with a… you get the point, while also seeing the characters’ perspectives of suddenly being part of that. I admit, some of the symbolism in the book is repetitive at times, but again, so are many fairy tales and literature alike. We treasure rather than complain about F. Scott Fitzgerald’s excessive use of colour. Good literature can take many forms. On that note, yes, the writing is very abstract. I enjoy my full sentences as much as the next person, but it was rather invigorating to just take in the imagery and mood once I let my expectations go.

I also valued the presence of LGBTQ+ characters without the book being about the fact that they’re queer. So often books use this as the sole reason for empowerment, or inversely, the sole reason for their problems, so it was refreshing to just take the characters for what they’re worth. Also, I wasn’t expecting this coming into the book as it wasn’t part of the back cover synopsis; it was just a nice treat! I wish more authors did this, as I, without any legit credentials other than being part of the LGBTQ+ community myself, feel that this is a good way to have more inclusion.

Overall, I highly recommend this to any story lover in the market for honey-sweet swirling plots and romantic imagery.

Happy reading,
-Beppa